Hiring Board Directors for SMEs: Why Corporate Experience Is Not Enough

Hiring Board Directors for SMEs: Why Corporate Experience Is Not Enough


Hiring Board Directors for SMEs: Why Corporate Experience Is Not Enough

Simon Roderick

 / 
September 4, 2026
 / 

An impressive corporate career can look extremely compelling when an SME is recruiting a CFO, COO, Chair or Non-Executive Director. The candidate may have worked for highly regarded businesses, led substantial teams and dealt with challenges considerably larger than those facing the company making the appointment.

Yet none of that automatically means they will be effective in an SME.

Smaller businesses create a different leadership environment. Board members are usually closer to day-to-day decisions, management teams are smaller and individual executives can have considerably broader influence. There may be less information, fewer specialist resources and nobody immediately available to take responsibility for a problem that falls between functions.

For founders, CEOs and investors recruiting board directors for SMEs, assessing whether somebody will actually enjoy and succeed in that environment is therefore just as important as assessing their technical experience.

Why SME Board Roles Are Different

In a large organisation, senior executives are generally supported by established structures. Finance, HR, legal, operations, technology and strategy may each have substantial teams of their own. Responsibilities are relatively clearly defined and information is produced through established reporting processes.

An SME board member may encounter something quite different.

A CFO can find themselves discussing a commercial problem that has little obvious connection to finance. A COO may be expected to improve processes while simultaneously helping the CEO think about organisational structure. A Chair might need to support a first-time CEO, manage investor expectations and help a founder adjust to a less operational role.

Building a leadership team?

Fram Professionals works with VC-backed, PE-backed and founder-led businesses across the UK. If you are considering hiring a Chief of Staff, COO, CFO or other senior leader, contact us on 01525 864 372 or email [email protected].
Discuss a Search

This breadth is often one of the attractions of joining an SME. Executives can see the consequences of their decisions, influence the whole organisation and work much closer to shareholders and customers.

But candidates need to want that.

Someone who has spent many years operating successfully with substantial infrastructure around them may find a smaller organisation liberating. Another person with an almost identical CV may find the lack of infrastructure frustrating within months.

Understanding that difference is an important part of SME board recruitment.

Start With What the Business Needs to Change

The strongest board recruitment processes usually begin with the reason for the appointment rather than the title.

An SME deciding that it needs a CFO, for example, should be able to explain what it wants that person to achieve. The priority might be improving forecasting, preparing for investment, strengthening cash management, completing acquisitions or giving the CEO a commercially minded senior finance partner.

Similarly, a business considering a COO appointment might initially believe it has an operations problem when the underlying issue is that too much responsibility remains concentrated around the founder.

The same principle applies to Chairs and Non-Executive Directors. Appointing an NED simply because a company has reached a stage where it feels it ought to have one rarely creates a particularly useful brief. The requirement becomes much clearer when the board can identify a specific gap in its collective experience, whether that is acquisitions, international expansion, institutional investment, succession or scaling an organisation.

The useful question is therefore not simply, "Who should we recruit?"

It is, "What will this business need to be better at over the next three to five years?"

Relevant Experience Does Not Always Mean Identical Experience

Once that question has been answered, the candidate specification can look quite different.

An SME preparing for its first international expansion may benefit more from somebody who has successfully internationalised a comparable business than from a candidate who has spent their entire career in precisely the same sector.

A founder-led company preparing for external investment may value an executive who understands institutional shareholders, governance and transactions.

An acquisitive SME might prioritise a CFO, COO or NED who has repeatedly integrated businesses rather than somebody whose experience comes entirely from organic growth.

Sector knowledge can still matter, particularly where regulation, technical complexity or customer relationships create genuine barriers to entry. However, making every desirable characteristic essential can reduce the candidate market very quickly.

Exact sector experience, identical company size, previous board experience, a particular qualification, local geography and several specific commercial achievements may each sound reasonable in isolation. Combined, they can create a candidate profile that barely exists.

Good board recruitment therefore requires a distinction between experience that genuinely reduces appointment risk and criteria that simply make a CV feel reassuring.

Can a Corporate Executive Adapt to an SME?

This deserves particular attention when candidates come from much larger organisations.

Previous seniority is not the same as suitability.

Decisions in an SME may need to be made quickly and with imperfect information. Support functions are smaller. Executives often work across responsibilities that would be divided between several departments in a corporate organisation. A CEO may ask a board colleague to contribute to an issue well outside their formal remit simply because their judgement is useful and there is nobody else in the business with comparable experience.

Some executives actively want this.

They are attracted by greater autonomy, closer relationships with shareholders and the opportunity to influence a whole company rather than one part of a much larger organisation.

Others discover that what they really valued was the infrastructure around their previous position.

This is why motivation needs to be tested carefully. Wanting "something more entrepreneurial" is not enough. Candidates should understand what working in a smaller business will actually mean.

How comfortable are they making decisions without extensive analysis? Do they enjoy building systems and teams, or prefer leading functions that are already mature? How close do they want to remain to execution? Are they prepared to solve problems personally when necessary?

The answers can be more revealing than the size of the candidate's previous job title.

Working With Founders Requires Judgement

Founder-led SMEs create another important consideration.

A founder may have spent twenty years building the company and possess an enormous amount of knowledge that has never been formally documented. Customer relationships may depend partly on them. Employees may be accustomed to approaching them directly and significant decisions may historically have rested on their judgement.

A new board director cannot ignore that history.

Trying to introduce corporate processes everywhere immediately can damage some of the characteristics that made the company successful. Equally, avoiding necessary change because "that is how the founder has always done it" does not help the organisation develop.

Strong SME board directors are often able to introduce greater discipline without behaving as though the existing business needs to be rescued from itself.

That balance becomes particularly important as companies scale. The objective is usually to make the organisation less dependent on individual people without losing the entrepreneurial qualities that allowed it to grow.

Board Recruitment Ahead of Investment, Acquisition or Sale

Transactions often expose leadership gaps that were less obvious beforehand.

A business preparing for external investment may discover that its management information is not sufficiently sophisticated for institutional shareholders. An acquisition programme may require integration experience that does not currently exist around the board table. A potential sale can highlight how dependent the organisation remains on its founder.

Recruiting ahead of these events gives a new board member time to understand the company before the pressure increases.

Waiting until a transaction is underway creates a much harder appointment. The new executive has to learn the organisation while simultaneously dealing with an event they may have been recruited specifically to manage.

For growth businesses, leadership planning should therefore form part of transaction readiness rather than being considered only once a capability gap becomes urgent.

Succession Rarely Means Replacing Someone Like-for-Like

Succession creates a different challenge.

When a founder, CEO or long-serving director begins considering a reduction in their involvement, the obvious response can be to look for somebody capable of replacing them.

That may not be possible — or desirable.

A founder may have accumulated responsibility for sales, strategy, important customer relationships, recruitment and operational decisions over twenty years. Finding another individual who combines exactly the same capabilities is unlikely.

The better question may be how those responsibilities should be structured in the future.

Some might sit with a new CEO. Others could move to a CFO or commercial leader. A Chair might provide experience that previously sat informally with the founder.

Succession planning can therefore create an opportunity to design the leadership team the future business needs rather than recreating the structure that developed around one individual.

What Makes a Good SME Non-Executive Director?

Similar principles apply to NED recruitment.

An SME does not necessarily benefit from collecting high-profile names around its board table. It needs Non-Executive Directors who will contribute relevant experience, challenge management appropriately and devote enough time to understand the business.

Previous NED experience can be useful, but operating experience should not be overlooked.

A current or recently retired executive who has recently encountered the company's next major challenge may bring highly relevant knowledge even if they have held relatively few non-executive appointments.

The balance across the board matters more than the prestige of individual CVs.

The Chair is particularly important where ownership, management and board relationships overlap. They may need to support a first-time CEO, help a founder step away from operational decisions, manage investors and improve board discipline without introducing unnecessary bureaucracy.

Personal judgement and credibility can matter every bit as much as the scale of organisations somebody has previously chaired.

Why Advertising Alone Can Restrict the Candidate Market

Many of the strongest potential SME board candidates are not actively looking for another role.

Some are already running businesses. Others have established portfolio careers or successful corporate positions and will only consider moving when the company, shareholders and challenge are sufficiently interesting.

Executive search allows businesses to consider the relevant candidate market rather than limiting the appointment to people actively applying at that particular moment.

It can also uncover less obvious candidates.

A Finance Director who has helped another growth business through investment and expansion may be ready for their first CFO role. A divisional leader from a larger organisation may have the commercial breadth required to join an SME board. A former founder could make an excellent NED for another entrepreneur if they have the judgement to advise rather than attempt to run the company themselves.

Assessing capability and potential rather than simply matching previous job titles can significantly broaden the market.

Giving Senior Candidates a Reason to Join

SMEs cannot always compete with larger organisations purely on basic salary, but senior candidates rarely make career decisions on salary alone.

Scope, autonomy, equity, future growth, ownership and the opportunity to have genuine influence can all form part of the proposition.

This makes it important to understand why the role itself is interesting.

Candidates considering an SME board appointment will want to understand the ownership structure, financial performance, strategy, existing leadership team and what shareholders expect them to achieve. They are assessing the CEO, founders and investors just as carefully as the company is assessing them.

A recruitment process therefore needs to communicate the opportunity rather than simply the responsibilities.

Recruiting Board Directors for SMEs

Fram Professionals works with SMEs, growth-stage and founder-led companies, alongside VC-backed, private equity-backed, AIM-listed and PISCES businesses across the UK.

We recruit CFOs, COOs, Chairs, Non-Executive Directors and other senior leaders when businesses are strengthening management teams, adding new capability or preparing for another stage of development.

For SMEs, successful board recruitment is rarely about finding the most impressive CV available. It is about finding somebody whose experience is relevant to where the company is going and whose working style suits the environment they are joining.

Corporate experience can be extremely valuable. So can sector expertise, previous board appointments and experience of larger organisations.

The important question is whether the candidate can apply that experience effectively inside this particular business.

For an SME, that distinction can determine whether a new director merely adds another impressive biography to the company website or genuinely increases the capability around the board table.

About Fram Professionals

Fram Professionals supports VC-backed, PE-backed and founder-led businesses as they scale leadership teams. We advise on key hires including Chief Operating Officers, Chief of Staffs, CFOs and commercial leaders, helping growth companies build the capability required for their next stage of development. We are the sister company of Fram Search, with over sixteen years of VC market relationships.

Contact us at [email protected] or call 01525 864 372 to discuss a search.

VC-Backed Companies

Growth & Founder-Led Companies

Executive Search

Share this Post