Board Member Search for Private Companies
Simon Roderick
A private company rarely decides to appoint a new board member simply because it wants another person around the table.
More often, something about the business is changing. The founders may be considering external investment, the company could be preparing for acquisitions, succession may have become a serious discussion, or the existing directors may recognise that the next stage of growth requires experience they do not currently possess.
A board member search for a private company should begin with that change rather than with a generic description of the person the board thinks it wants.
This is particularly important because private company boards can be very different from one another.
In one business, the board may consist largely of founders and executive directors who have worked together for years. In another, venture capital or private equity investors may already have representation.
A larger privately owned company might have an independent Chair and several Non-Executive Directors, while a scaling founder-led business could be making its first external board appointment.
The right board member depends heavily on what is already there.
Start With What Is Missing From the Board
Before beginning a search, it is useful to look at the board as a whole.
If the company expects to make acquisitions over the next three years, does anybody around the table have meaningful experience of buying and integrating businesses?
If international growth is central to the strategy, has somebody managed that transition before?
If the founders are contemplating investment or an eventual exit, does the board contain people who understand what those processes look like from the company side rather than simply from the perspective of an adviser?
Thinking in terms of missing experience produces a much more useful search than beginning with a familiar phrase such as "experienced private company NED".
Building a leadership team?
It also helps prevent boards from recruiting people whose backgrounds duplicate expertise they already possess.
This is one of the reasons board, legal, governance and compliance recruitment should begin with the structure and future requirements of the organisation rather than simply a job title.
Board Member Recruitment Is Different From Executive Recruitment
This is one of the important differences between a board member search and recruiting a senior executive.
A CFO or Commercial Director is normally being hired to take ownership of a defined area of the company.
A Non-Executive Director or Chair should be considered partly in terms of what they add to the collective capability of the board.
An exceptional candidate can still be the wrong appointment if their experience is already heavily represented around the table.
The question is therefore not simply whether an individual is impressive. It is whether adding that individual makes the board more capable of dealing with the decisions the business is likely to face.
Does the Company Need a Chair, NED or Another Type of Director?
The role itself also needs to be clear.
Private companies sometimes use "board member" as a broad description covering quite different appointments.
The company might need an independent Non-Executive Director, a Chair, an investor representative or an executive director with a particular functional responsibility. Those roles carry different expectations and should lead to different candidate markets.
A Non-Executive Director might be recruited because the company needs independent challenge and experience of a particular strategic issue.
A Chair has a wider responsibility for the effectiveness of the board and often needs to manage relationships between founders, executives, shareholders and other directors.
In a founder-led business, the Chair may also become an important sounding board for a CEO who has previously had relatively few people capable of challenging them as an equal.
Does a Private Company Need an Experienced Portfolio NED?
Not necessarily.
Searching beyond obvious board candidates can improve the outcome considerably.
An experienced private company CEO or CFO may have exactly the perspective another business needs without having built a long portfolio of Non-Executive Director positions.
Current executives can bring recent knowledge of markets, technology, customers and talent, while established portfolio NEDs may contribute experience gained from seeing similar problems across several organisations.
Neither profile is automatically preferable.
The relevant question is what experience the board needs and whether the individual can apply it effectively in a non-executive environment.
Will a Corporate Board Member Work in a Private Company?
The best private company board member is not necessarily the person with the most prestigious corporate career.
Someone who has spent decades inside very large listed organisations may bring valuable experience but find the realities of a smaller private company unfamiliar.
Information may be less complete, management resources thinner and responsibilities less neatly separated. Directors can find themselves much closer to practical commercial issues than they expected.
Equally, familiarity with entrepreneurial businesses should not be confused with simply agreeing with the founder.
A useful independent director needs to be able to challenge assumptions without turning every disagreement into a governance contest.
Private businesses often benefit from people who understand why greater structure is required as a company grows while recognising that importing large-company processes wholesale can be counterproductive.
We examine this question in more depth in our guide to hiring board directors for SMEs, including how to assess whether corporate experience will translate successfully into a smaller and more entrepreneurial organisation.
How Important Is the Relationship With the Founder?
In growth and founder-led businesses, the relationship between a new board member and the founder deserves particular attention.
The founder may still be the largest shareholder, CEO and central source of knowledge about the business. An independent director therefore needs sufficient credibility to challenge them while understanding the history and entrepreneurial culture that shaped the company.
A board member who agrees with everything adds little independent value.
Someone who treats every disagreement as evidence that governance needs to become more corporate can be equally ineffective.
The strongest relationship is often one in which challenge is accepted because the director has demonstrated sound judgement and an understanding of the business rather than because their title gives them formal authority.
What Should You Look for in a Private Company Board Member?
Motivation is worth examining closely during a board member search.
Candidates may be interested in portfolio careers for very different reasons. Some genuinely enjoy working with ambitious management teams and can bring experience accumulated across several businesses. Others are primarily attracted by the idea of holding board positions.
The distinction tends to become apparent when conversations move away from the title and towards the actual work involved.
Good candidates should want to understand the company.
They will ask about the shareholders, management team, strategy, financial position and expectations of the board. They will want to know why the appointment is being made and what the other directors contribute.
If a founder is still heavily involved, they may sensibly ask how decisions are made and how open the founder is to challenge.
How Should You Assess Board Candidates?
The company should be equally inquisitive.
Previous board positions provide useful context, but interviews should examine what the individual contributed when circumstances became difficult.
How have they handled disagreement between shareholders and management?
Have they supported a CEO through a period of underperformance?
What happened when an acquisition failed to deliver?
How have they approached succession or the replacement of a senior executive?
These questions get much closer to the value of a board member than a list of companies where somebody has previously served.
The board should also distinguish between somebody who has experienced an event and somebody who genuinely contributed to its outcome. Sitting on a board during an acquisition, investment round or international expansion does not necessarily mean the individual played a meaningful role in navigating it.
How Much Time Should a Private Company NED Commit?
The time commitment needs to be discussed realistically.
A board appointment described as a handful of meetings each year can become considerably more demanding during fundraising, acquisitions, leadership changes or periods of difficult trading.
Candidates with extensive portfolios may look highly experienced but have limited capacity when the company most needs them.
Understanding what somebody can contribute between scheduled meetings is often as important as confirming their attendance at them.
This should form part of the search brief rather than being left until the preferred candidate is discussing terms.
What Changes in an Investor-Backed Private Company?
For VC-backed and private equity-backed companies, shareholder expectations add another dimension.
Investor directors may already bring substantial financial and transaction experience, meaning the next independent board member could add more value through sector knowledge, operational scale, international expansion or commercial leadership.
Adding another director with a similar investment background may increase the size of the board without materially increasing its collective capability.
Conversely, a founder-owned business preparing for its first institutional investment may deliberately want somebody who understands how relationships between management teams and professional investors change after a transaction.
The relevant experience therefore depends partly on the existing shareholder and board structure rather than simply the company's ownership label.
Board Recruitment Ahead of Investment, Acquisition or Succession
The timing of a board appointment can matter as much as the candidate profile.
A company expecting a major transaction in twelve or eighteen months may benefit from adding relevant experience before the process begins rather than recruiting once the business is already under pressure.
The same applies to succession.
If a founder expects eventually to reduce their involvement, an independent Chair or NED can sometimes contribute to that transition long before a formal leadership change occurs.
Bringing somebody onto the board early gives them time to understand the company, build relationships with shareholders and management and contribute before the event they were partly recruited to help navigate.
Why Executive Search Can Be Useful for Board Appointments
Many potentially valuable private company board members are not actively searching for another position.
They may be CEOs, former founders, experienced functional leaders or existing directors who would consider a particular company because the business and challenge are interesting.
A structured executive search can map that wider population, approach people directly and compare different candidate profiles before the board decides which type adds the greatest value.
This matters because a search can also test the board's original assumptions.
A company may begin convinced that it needs a former CEO and eventually discover that its existing directors already provide strong general management experience while the real gap is much more specific.
The purpose of search is therefore not simply to find people who match the original specification. It can help the company understand the candidate market well enough to determine whether the specification itself is right.
Board Member Search With Fram Professionals
Fram Professionals works with founder-led, growth-stage, VC-backed, private equity-backed, AIM-listed and PISCES businesses across the UK.
Our work includes senior leadership and board appointments such as Chairs, Non-Executive Directors, CFOs, Finance Directors and other executives who can become important as private companies develop.
We are also the sister company of Fram Search, a specialist financial services executive search firm with more than sixteen years of market experience. This provides access to established relationships across financial services, fintech and the investment community, which can be particularly relevant where private companies are looking for board members with experience of investment, financial markets or working with institutional shareholders.
A successful private company board does not need the most impressive collection of CVs it can assemble.
It needs a combination of people whose experience is relevant to the decisions the business is likely to face.
The purpose of a board member search is to identify what is missing, find people who can genuinely provide it and establish whether they will work effectively with the founders, shareholders and executives already around the table.
If you are planning a board member search for a private company, Fram Professionals can discuss the experience your board may need, the relevant UK candidate market and how a targeted search could be structured.
About Fram Professionals
Fram Professionals supports VC-backed, PE-backed and founder-led businesses as they scale leadership teams. We advise on key hires including Chief Operating Officers, Chief of Staffs, CFOs and commercial leaders, helping growth companies build the capability required for their next stage of development. We are the sister company of Fram Search, with over sixteen years of VC market relationships.
Contact us at [email protected] or call 01525 864 372 to discuss a search.
Related articles:
Share this Post